À la folie… pas du tout (He Loves Me… He Loves Me Not)

Rating: startstartstart

He Loves Me, He Loves Me Not BoxThis is one of those films that has all the parts for greatness but just can’t put them together. This film stars the radiant pixie Audrey Tautou (Amélie) as Angélique, a struggling but talented art student, who is wrapped up in an “affair” with an older married cardiologist, Loïc (Samuel Le BihanRed) when things begin to decend into unspeakable horror. Unfortunately, I can’t go too far into the plot of this film with out giving out a spoiler for those who can really suspend disbelief.

However, I can say that the acting is quite good. Ms. Tautou is a dead ringer for the incredibly innocent Audrey Hepburn and yet pulls off this dark part with very little difficulty, even turning her crooked-tooth smile into an almost sinister appearance. Her male counterpart, Mr. Le Bihan does and equally good job of portraying confusion and fear as his life falls out of control.

No, the problem with this film is that it is a really arty collection of gimmicks used in one form or another in every suspense film ever made. Within 10 minutes of the beginning of the film, you know exactly what is going on and where it will end. Then you must sit through the rest of the film while they explain it to you. Even the “surprise” twist at the end was entirely expected by the clichéd design of the circumstances. A thriller is a fine and good thing. Even to use some of the standard gimmicks is necessary. But you must always add something new to the form to make it work.

In many ways, this is an standard Hollywood thriller with a light French accent. In fact, I wouldn’t recommend it at all if it weren’t for the fine performances of the actors. As such, give this a watch after a good bottle of wine with a mind well cleared of reality.

One thought on “À la folie… pas du tout (He Loves Me… He Loves Me Not)

  1. Yeah, good movie. Have you seen Amelie? (I sure that’s not the correct way to spell it) or Dirty Pretty things? Both have ol’ Audrey being amazingly cute, but in the latter she shows some acting chops as well. Rent them, I would highly recommend both. Also, I was hoping to find “Batman Begins” reviewed, but I guess you haven’t made it around to that yet. I’ll see you over a tanq/tonic soon!

Leave a Reply